Have you got a story to tell? Do you have pictures or video clips to share? GET IN TOUCH »
2:50pm Monday 9th July 2007
Plans to create a symbolic Jewish boundary around Borehamwood were approved at a planning meeting on Thursday night.
The public gallery in Hertsmere Borough Council's chamber was packed with people waiting to hear the decision on whether 34 sets of poles joined by wire can be put up around the town to create an eruv.
Once the poles are put up, there will be an area in which Orthodox Jews can carry out tasks which are usually prohibited during the Sabbath, such as carrying or pushing.
Currently, observant Jews who have small children or have to walk with an aid cannot leave the house on the Sabbath and therefore cannot visit the synagogue.
Although two councillors on the panel abstained from the vote, the other seven members approved it.
Speaking against the proposals, John Brown, of Morpeth Avenue, Borehamwood, said: "In certain areas there is almost a forest of poles, signs and other street furniture. The council, if it gives approval, wishes to increase this.
"We will have a situation where individuals will have poles outside their house. People with low walls are going to have a pole put in front of it. What security is going ot be offered to these people?"
But speaking in favour of the application, David Freedman, of Markham Close, Borehamwood, said: "As the Elstree and Borehamwood Jewish community continues to grow and thrive, the existence of an eruv will permit a substantially greater degree of mobility for those observant Jews with young families and the less mobile, so that all can take part in communal activities. It will have no impact whatsoever on anybody else."
Hertsmere planning officer Chris Lewcock noted a small number of gateways' will be erected just within the Green Belt, and a few poles are in positions which are quite exposed. But the applicant, the Ebor Eruv Charitable Trust, agreed to make some small amendments to specific locations. Councillor Robert Gamble, who abstained from the vote, said: "There is no finesse to the application. We have rather inadequate plans. It is just not good enough." But Councillor Harvey Cohen said: "I really don't understand how wires can affect other faiths at all. The eruv in Barnet is now an established fixture which is barely noticeable and attracts no antisocial behaviour. "It has not changed the social, religious or multicultural mix in the borough and nor will it here in Hertsmere."
Raymond, Borehamwood says...
5:41pm Wed 11 Jul 07
Terry, Bedfordshire says...
6:16pm Wed 11 Jul 07
anonymous, borehamwood says...
9:10am Thu 12 Jul 07
Dave, says...
10:01am Thu 12 Jul 07
Anon2, Borehamwood says...
10:17am Thu 12 Jul 07
John, 726-349 says...
10:30am Thu 12 Jul 07
quoteAnon2 "No doubt the eruv poles/fencing/bits of wire will be pulled down as soon as erected. Well intended gesture but just another waste of council money really."
anoni, Borehamwood says...
10:33am Thu 12 Jul 07
Len, says...
11:35am Thu 12 Jul 07
bejesus, says...
12:17pm Thu 12 Jul 07
anoni wrote:Alright, its Jewish funded. Who will pay for the maintenance e.g if they are torn down or vandalised?
But the council isn't even paying anything - it's all being funded by the Jewish community. How is this a waste of council money?
Anon2, says...
12:21pm Thu 12 Jul 07
John wrote:If a 6ft cross were to be erected in Borehamwood by the Protestant faith, I am sure if would suffer the same fate, especially if it heralded all the press the eruv has. Mind you, the cross probably wouldn't get planning permission!
quoteAnon2 "No doubt the eruv poles/fencing/bits of wire will be pulled down as soon as erected. Well intended gesture but just another waste of council money really." As an anti-semetic gesture its good is it?By the way its financed by the Jewish Community so you wont have to pay for. You can sleep easy now and hope they are pulled down if that makes you happy.
John, says...
12:33pm Thu 12 Jul 07
Anon2 wrote:I couldn't care less if a 6ft cross was errected. Why should I?Why should it also get the amount of press a few poles are getting? Is there something you have against a particular faith?
John wrote:If a 6ft cross were to be erected in Borehamwood by the Protestant faith, I am sure if would suffer the same fate, especially if it heralded all the press the eruv has. Mind you, the cross probably wouldn't get planning permission! I sleep perfectly at night, thank you.quoteAnon2 "No doubt the eruv poles/fencing/bits of wire will be pulled down as soon as erected. Well intended gesture but just another waste of council money really." As an anti-semetic gesture its good is it?By the way its financed by the Jewish Community so you wont have to pay for. You can sleep easy now and hope they are pulled down if that makes you happy.
Maxine, says...
12:35pm Thu 12 Jul 07
bejesus wrote:Maintenace is funded by the Jewish community as well. I have no doubt that with that knowledge any vandilism will be truley welcomed by some.
anoni wrote: But the council isn't even paying anything - it's all being funded by the Jewish community. How is this a waste of council money?Alright, its Jewish funded. Who will pay for the maintenance e.g if they are torn down or vandalised?
Anon2, says...
12:43pm Thu 12 Jul 07
John wrote:Nothing at all against any faith. We are all God's children.
Anon2 wrote:I couldn\'t care less if a 6ft cross was errected. Why should I?Why should it also get the amount of press a few poles are getting? Is there something you have against a particular faith?John wrote:If a 6ft cross were to be erected in Borehamwood by the Protestant faith, I am sure if would suffer the same fate, especially if it heralded all the press the eruv has. Mind you, the cross probably wouldn\'t get planning permission! I sleep perfectly at night, thank you.quoteAnon2 \"No doubt the eruv poles/fencing/bits of wire will be pulled down as soon as erected. Well intended gesture but just another waste of council money really.\" As an anti-semetic gesture its good is it?By the way its financed by the Jewish Community so you wont have to pay for. You can sleep easy now and hope they are pulled down if that makes you happy.
Raymond, Borehamwood says...
1:26pm Thu 12 Jul 07
Raymond, Borehamwood says...
1:27pm Thu 12 Jul 07
Alucard, says...
1:59pm Thu 12 Jul 07
bob, Borehamwood says...
5:17pm Thu 12 Jul 07
CL, Borehamwood says...
6:34pm Thu 12 Jul 07
lorraine, borehamwood says...
1:09pm Fri 13 Jul 07
bob wrote:I live on a council estate,my family have never been in any trouble,we are decent people.If council estates are full of scum ,then why have we got 3 jewish familys living,in my rd?is it because they are scum to ,you are racist.
At the end of the day, the only opposition to the Eruv is by ignorant anti-semites. Most normal people don\'t care. It won\'t affect anyone and no one will even see it. Therefore, there is no basis for the hatred of it. It is purely a racial thing by a few old school racists. Look at the original quote from the ringleader \"i don\'t want to live in a jewish state\" - its laughable. The only ghettos i see in Borehamwood are council ghettos full of undesirable scum bags
DD, says...
6:39pm Fri 13 Jul 07
Nick T, says...
8:37am Mon 16 Jul 07
DD wrote:A remark such "as I dont want to live in a Jewish state" because 34 poles are being errected is to me racist. Why Borehamwood suddenly becomes a Jewish state because of this is simply ignorance beyond contempt. Also its not gypsies a people I have a problem with, its the fact that they will not contribute any council tax and therefore the clear up and everyday policing will have to be financed by those of us who do pay council tax's. For that reason I cannot see where double standards come into play with our councilors.
In response to Nick T, I don't believe that at any time has anybody, who protested against the eruv, made a racist remark. I believe their concern was about disharmony among the many religions residing in Boreham Wood. Perhaps you should get your facts right before you call people racist. And, by the way, I agree with what you say about the mess etc the gypsies leave behind but I really do think that there are factions in Boreham Wood who have double standards - some of your Councillors among them.
bob, borehamwood says...
11:18am Tue 17 Jul 07
anon, Croxdale Road says...
8:54pm Tue 17 Jul 07
DD, says...
9:12pm Tue 17 Jul 07
bob, Borehamwood says...
3:25pm Wed 18 Jul 07
DD wrote:Just because they are jewish councillors does not mean they are prejudiced or have an interest. Maybe all non-jewish councillors are prejudiced anti the eruv?
Double standards come into play with your Councillors because not one of the Jewish members of the Planning committee declared a prejudicial interest regarding the eruv which they should have done and they should not have been able to vote for it.
Terry Davis, Bedfordshire says...
6:54pm Wed 18 Jul 07
Nick T, 845-367 says...
8:16am Thu 19 Jul 07
Terry Davis wrote:To Terry David, please read my posts more carefully. I have never reffered once to councul tennants or called gypsies "scum". I reffered to Gypsies not contributing to council tax's and therefore who will pay for there rubbish collections and general policing? Secondly if you want to debate the state of the roads then fine maybe you should club together with the rest of us and help pay for them to fixed just as the Jewish Community is doing to fund the eruv.
Bob & Nick T You are the most bigoted posters on here, your racist comments about gypsies and your view that most council Tennant\\\'s are scum thieves, is a disgrace. You have tried (with out success) to divert attention from the subject and turn the whole issue on its head by accusing dissenters of being anti semitic...Pathetic and shows your lack of intelligence by using the argument of convenience. I notice not one poster commented on my original gripe about the council doing nothing about the roads.Just proves where priorities lie.
Nick T, Borehamwood says...
8:22am Thu 19 Jul 07
Terry Davis wrote:To Terry Davis, please read my posts more carefully. I have never once reffered to either council tennants or gypsies as "scum". My refference was to Gypsies not contributing to council tax's and therefore who will pay for their rubbish collections and general policing? Secondly if you want to debate the state of the roads then fine maybe you should club together with the rest of us and help pay for them to be fixed just as the Jewish Community is doing to fund their eruv and its maintenace.
Bob & Nick T You are the most bigoted posters on here, your racist comments about gypsies and your view that most council Tennant\\\\\\\'s are scum thieves, is a disgrace. You have tried (with out success) to divert attention from the subject and turn the whole issue on its head by accusing dissenters of being anti semitic...Pathetic and shows your lack of intelligence by using the argument of convenience. I notice not one poster commented on my original gripe about the council doing nothing about the roads.Just proves where priorities lie.
bob, Borehamwood says...
8:31am Thu 19 Jul 07
anon3, says...
10:35am Thu 19 Jul 07
Glen R, Borehamwood says...
8:46am Fri 20 Jul 07
DD wrote:So using that warped logic I suppose that when anything regarding the Church comes up then every Christian councillor should not be able to vote because they have a "prejudicial interest". What utter rubbish you talk.
Double standards come into play with your Councillors because not one of the Jewish members of the Planning committee declared a prejudicial interest regarding the eruv which they should have done and they should not have been able to vote for it.
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Need a change? Search thousands of jobs locally and across the UK.
Search Now »
Find friendship and romance online with Two’s Company
Search Now »
Tens of thousands of houses and flats for sale and rent.
Search Now »
Every major make and model, thousands of options to choose from.
Search Now »
Terry Davis, Bedfordshire says...
5:21pm Wed 11 Jul 07
Instead they use their 'valuable' time to bottle it over a contentious issue and vote unanimously on some stupid symbolic poles which will in all probability be pulled down the minute they have gone up.
Considering most of these councillors live out side of Borehamwood I suppose the welfare and safety of local children is of no concern to them but thats all right so long as a few people can now drive right up to the front door of their place of worship,park over pavements,clog the streets of Croxdale and surrounding roads all's well with the world.
Well done the Burghers of Hertsmere B.C. once again you prove that you have the interests of the local people of Borehamwood at heart.